Dr. Bernd Fleischmann | NARRATIVE #221 by Robert Cibis

Here is a version of about 40 minutes without restrictions – our OVALmedia subscribers can enjoy the full programme.

Audio onlyShort version · 38 min
Subscribers can listen to the full conversation (1:42:53). See OVAL subscriptionAlso as a podcast

Watch the full episode with OVAL Abo

Above you can watch a short version.

from €7 / month · cancel anytime · this and all other films, shows and articles

The Thermal Deception

Engineer, scientist and writer Dr. Bernd Fleischmann deconstructs the prevailing climate narrative as a mixture of physical misunderstandings, flawed models and politically motivated scaremongering. One of Fleischmann’s central criticisms is aimed at the greatly simplified and often wrong explanations of the so-called greenhouse effect given by organisations such as Greenpeace. A real greenhouse, after all, does not work through reflected radiation, but quite simply because the glass or plastic film prevents air exchange and cooling convection.

With regard to the Earth’s atmosphere, too, Fleischmann corrects fundamental myths, such as the claim that without an atmosphere the global average temperature would be a hostile minus 18 degrees Celsius. This figure, he says, is based on the 100-year-old, unrealistic construct of a “black body” with a uniformly constant temperature. The example of the Moon, which is the same distance from the Sun and fluctuates between minus 170 degrees and over 100 degrees, shows that simple averaging is not permissible because of the physical laws of radiation and in fact leads to a far lower reference temperature of around minus 70 degrees. As for greenhouse gases such as CO2, he makes clear that they do not simply “radiate back” infrared radiation to the Earth like a mirror. Instead they absorb radiation quanta and convert them into thermal energy through hundreds of thousands of collisions with other air molecules – a process called thermalisation. In addition, the physical degree of saturation of CO2 in the atmosphere is already so high within the first few metres that even a doubling of today’s CO2 content would at best lead to minimal warming of around 0.5 degrees Celsius, but not to the 1 to 6 degrees forecast by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), which are only calculated through unproven positive feedback effects in the models. The often-quoted consensus of 97 per cent of scientists supporting an impending climate catastrophe is, according to Fleischmann, a demonstrable lie in any case.

Fleischmann does not see the actual drivers of the observed global warming primarily in CO2, but in natural and atmospheric cycles. Satellite data, he says, show that a decline in global cloud cover – paradoxically caused by cleaner air, the disappearance of industrial aerosols and stricter emission standards for marine diesel – has led to a massive increase in incoming and absorbed solar radiation. In parts of Central Europe alone, measurable solar radiation has increased by 10 to 20 per cent over the last 40 years, which almost completely explains the rise in temperature. In addition, ocean cycles such as the El Niño phenomenon caused significant short-term temperature increases of up to half a degree globally through changed wind patterns, which explains the record-breaking media reports of 2023 and 2024. At the same time, he rejects historical comparisons in the media as deliberate deception. Reports of the “warmest year in 130,000 years” often deliberately conceal that in the Eemian warm period it was, entirely naturally, so hot that hippopotamuses lived in Central Europe. Around 5,000 years ago, too, when the advanced civilisations emerged, it was warmer than today and today’s Sahara was a green landscape – without any human industry. The higher CO2 level of the present also has far more positive effects than reported: it acts as plant food and causes a measurable “global greening”, in which plants survive with less water and grow better, especially in dry regions such as the Sahel, India or Australia.

A significant part of the conversation is devoted to the question of why these arguments are rigorously excluded from public debate. Cibis describes the shift in journalism towards so-called “impact producing”, in which media content no longer informs neutrally but is deliberately embedded in campaigns in order to bring about specific behaviour in viewers. In this context Fleischmann also sharply attacks leading media such as the Süddeutsche Zeitung, which he accuses of deliberately spreading false reports. A prominent example, he says, was the scandalisation of a supposed 20 degrees in Antarctica. This measurement came from Seymour Island, a small, glacier-free island north of the Antarctic Circle in the middle of high summer, while the actual Antarctic mass has, if anything, cooled over recent decades due to temperature inversions. He also accuses well-known science communicators such as Harald Lesch of spreading untruths in licence-fee-funded formats, misrepresenting basic physical laws and uncritically parroting the political narrative.

Fleischmann also warns of the growing danger of artificial intelligence. Systems such as ChatGPT, he says, are deeply programmed through filters, safety guidelines and training data to systematically reinforce the mainstream narrative and to optimise the user for perceived consensus trust rather than objective truth, even when well-founded physical counter-evidence is presented in the discussion. How strongly economic interests steer the climate discourse is also shown by the conduct of billionaires such as Bill Gates: his latest appeal to save the net-zero targets serves primarily to protect around 36 companies in his investment portfolio, all of which depend on state climate subsidies, from the looming political change of course in the USA.

In summary, Cibis and Fleischmann regard the climate narrative as a kind of psychological warfare against one’s own population, aimed at exercising far-reaching control through irrational fear and by conjuring up “tipping points”. Excesses such as the national CO2 budget legitimised by the Federal Constitutional Court, which Germany is soon set to exhaust completely, or concepts such as “15-minute cities”, according to Fleischmann, carry the risk of drastically ruining the economy and civil liberties. And all this, he says, has no effect whatsoever on the global climate, while great powers such as China calmly add three times more fossil energy capacity than even exists in Germany. In closing, Robert Cibis and Dr. Bernd Fleischmann appeal to viewers to distrust the established scaremongering, to question authorities radically and to be aware that the complexity of the global habitat can never be reliably calculated by computer models.

Outline

00:00:16 – 00:04:21 | Introduction and the Greenpeace narrative Robert Cibis introduces Dr. Bernd Fleischmann. He explains his background in physics and control engineering and begins by criticising the often wrong and greatly simplified presentations of the greenhouse effect by organisations such as Greenpeace.

00:04:21 – 00:10:39 | The myth of minus 18 degrees without an atmosphere Fleischmann deconstructs the claim that without an atmosphere the Earth would have a hostile minus 18 degrees Celsius. He explains that this figure is based on an outdated construct of a “black body” and points to the real extreme temperature fluctuations on the Moon (minus 170 to over 100 degrees), which make simple averaging physically impermissible.

00:10:39 – 00:17:43 | The physical reality of climate gases (thermalisation) An explanation of what greenhouse gases really do: they absorb infrared radiation and do not simply give it off like mirrors, but convert it into thermal energy through tens of thousands of collisions with other air molecules (thermalisation).

00:17:43 – 00:23:45 | The fallacy of the gardener’s greenhouse Fleischmann corrects the widespread image that the atmosphere works like the glass of a real greenhouse. A real greenhouse warms up primarily because cooling air exchange (convection) is blocked – an effect that works just as well with transparent plastic film as with glass.

00:23:45 – 00:27:16 | The physical saturation of CO2 Even the small share of CO2 in the atmosphere (0.04 per cent) is enough to almost saturate absorption at certain wavelengths (such as 15 micrometres) within the first few metres. Overlap with water vapour further weakens the isolated effect of additional CO2.

00:27:16 – 00:35:34 | The role of clouds and the failure of the models A discussion of the extremely complex role of clouds, which represent the greatest uncertainty factor in climate models, as they can cool or warm the climate depending on their altitude. Cibis and Fleischmann compare the failure of climate models with unreliable weather forecasts.

00:35:34 – 00:40:09 | Temperature inversion in Antarctica Fleischmann explains a paradoxical phenomenon: because of extreme temperature inversions, in which the upper layers of air are warmer than the icy ground, CO2 in Antarctica radiates more heat into space during the Antarctic winter half-year than comes from the ground, which leads to a cooling effect.

00:40:09 – 00:48:20 | Artificial intelligence and the reinforcement of the mainstream narrative A digression on the bias of AI systems such as ChatGPT. Fleischmann explains that these programs have no internal fact-checking, but systematically repeat the official narrative through training data, safety guidelines and optimisation for so-called “user trust”.

00:48:20 – 00:54:29 | The lie of the 97 per cent consensus The often-quoted scientific consensus of 97 per cent in favour of man-made warming is exposed as deliberate deception and a targeted PR strategy. Cibis compares this method with historical propaganda.

00:54:29 – 01:00:35 | The IPCC and false model feedbacks Fleischmann criticises the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) as a primarily political body. He explains that the “positive feedbacks” programmed into the computer models, which predict warming of 1 to 6 degrees, would be unstable and contradict the fact that the real climate of the last 10,000 years has been extremely stable.

01:00:35 – 01:10:45 | The real drivers of warming: fewer clouds and ocean cycles Satellite data show that the rise in temperature is primarily due to a global decline in cloud cover caused by cleaner air (e.g. new emission standards for ships). In addition, ocean cycles such as the El Niño phenomenon cause short-term but serious global temperature jumps through changed wind patterns.

01:10:45 – 01:15:41 | Historical warm periods vs. “the warmest year” Media reports of “the warmest year in 130,000 years” often deliberately leave out that in the natural Eemian warm period, before any industrial influence, it was so warm in Europe that hippopotamuses lived there. Around 5,000 years ago, too – when the first advanced civilisations formed – the climate was warmer and today’s Sahara was green.

01:15:41 – 01:21:25 | Economic motives: the example of Bill Gates An appeal by Bill Gates to keep to the global net-zero targets is analysed. It turns out that Gates mainly wants to save 36 companies in his “Breakthrough Energy” portfolio, which depend on climate subsidies, from bankruptcy.

01:21:25 – 01:26:33 | “Global greening” and the unfounded fear of tipping points Increased CO2 emissions have led to worldwide “global greening”, as plants grow better with more carbon dioxide and manage with less water in dry regions such as the Sahel. Fleischmann describes so-called “tipping points” as scientifically baseless alarmism.

01:26:33 – 01:38:53 | Media failure: Süddeutsche Zeitung, impact producing and Harald Lesch Sharp criticism of major media and prominent science communicators. The report of a supposed 20 degrees in Antarctica came from a completely atypical, glacier-free outlying island in high summer. Cibis places this in the trend of so-called “impact producing”, in which films no longer inform but are meant to change viewers’ behaviour like PR campaigns.

01:38:53 – 01:47:12 | Political agenda, economic ruin and conclusion The German CO2 budget legitimised by the Federal Constitutional Court and plans such as “15-minute cities” carry the risk of massive restrictions for the population and the economy. That Germany, as the only country, is phasing out coal and nuclear power at the same time is ineffective for the global climate, since China builds far more new coal-fired power stations every year. The programme closes with an appeal to let go of one’s own fear and to rely on a critical examination of the models.

Further programmes:

NARRATIVE #206 with Michael Limburg – The Greenhouse Deception

NARRATIVE #139 with Prof. Dr. Fritz Vahrenholt – The Energy Deception

Also visit Dr. Fleischmann’s website: Klima-Wahrheiten.de (in German)

Robert CibisAnd it says in the 2021 report that our new models vary more than the old ones. That's why this narrowing of the temperature range for a doubling of CO2 is of course not credible. That has nothing to do with science, that's politics. The whole IPCC is politics, of course. After all, it isn't an organization where scientists negotiate something among themselves, it's intergovernmental, so things are agreed between governments. Hello, my name is Robert Cibis. Welcome to a new episode of NARRATIVE. I'm very glad, very proud, very honored to be sitting here with Dr. Bernd Fleischmann. He is a scientist, entrepreneur and publicist, and not least an engineer. What I like very much is that this combines the practical with the pragmatic

and the theoretical. And that is needed these days more than ever. Before we dive into the conversation, I want to stress once more that our conversations can always be seen in full on our website, www.oval.media. There you'll also find the articles and everything else. All the other platforms are not as reliable in terms of visibility. To put it casually, sometimes we get shadow-banned there. That means, for example, on X it happened that the video was there. But even if you typed it into the search engine, you couldn't find it. Yet sometimes other videos are seen quite well on the same platform. I find that totally fascinating. And you might think, well, nobody was interested. But if you can't find it, that's of course something else. And that's why I always say, please, please go to our website, watch the videos there, get into the habit

Download as PDF

Never miss a show

New films, shows and articles by email – free, unsubscribe anytime.

Title and name are optional.

Your comment