Dr. Hannes Hofbauer | NARRATIVE #225 by Robert Cibis

Here is a version of about 30 minutes without restrictions – our OVALmedia subscribers can enjoy the full programme.

Audio onlyShort version · 29 min
Subscribers can listen to the full conversation (53:51). See OVAL subscriptionAlso as a podcast

Watch the full episode with OVAL Abo

Above you can watch a short version.

from €7 / month · cancel anytime · this and all other films, shows and articles

Civil Death

It begins inconspicuously, with an entry on a list. No courtroom, no indictment, no verdict – and yet a person’s life is over with the stroke of a pen. Accounts frozen, assets blocked, passport as good as surrendered, any travel impossible. Anyone who helps the person concerned becomes liable to prosecution themselves. It is precisely this mechanism that the Viennese historian and publisher Dr. Hannes Hofbauer lays bare in his new book “Aller Rechte beraubt. Mit außergerichtlichen EU-Sanktionen zum autoritären Staat” (“Stripped of All Rights: Extrajudicial EU Sanctions on the Road to the Authoritarian State”, Promedia Verlag, Vienna 2026).

Hofbauer places the European Union’s sanctions policy in a broader context. It is a tool in the conflict with Russia, forged since spring 2014 – since the coup on the Maidan. At first it targeted Russian and Ukrainian politicians, economists and oligarchs. But the instrument has grown. Around 2,700 people and organisations now fill Brussels’ lists, and for a good year they have also included citizens of the EU and Switzerland.

What is new, Hofbauer stresses, is the procedure – or more precisely, its absence. There is no indictment, no conviction, no defence. The accusations are “undermining the sovereignty of Ukraine” or “disinformation” – offences that could not be tried before any regular court. That is exactly why, the author says, the sanctions regime is used. He calls the consequence by its historical name: civil death. As a historian, Hofbauer traces the line back to the medieval ban, to outlawry. Whoever was declared an outlaw was cast out of the community and became a “forest-goer”; his wife was considered a widow, his children orphans. “We believed this had long been overcome,” says Hofbauer. “In this case it is returning in a terrible way.”

How can something like this happen under the rule of law? Hofbauer’s answer goes to the construction principle of the Union. National executives – the ministers, literally the “servants” – raise themselves at EU level in the Council to legislative power, switch off the judiciary and decide who goes on the list. This contradicts everything one learns at school about the separation of powers. He is surprised that the legal profession does not protest more loudly.

He uses concrete cases to show that legal recourse leads nowhere. The former Ukrainian president won twice before the European General Court – and was listed anew by Brussels each time. A certain victory on paper, without any consequence. Conversely, it turns out that political will does indeed work: the Slovak biker Jozef Hambálek, European representative of the Russian “Night Wolves”, was taken off the list again by Prime Minister Robert Fico. And the Russian Patriarch Kirill never got onto it at all, because several states, led by Hungary, prevented it. Hofbauer’s conclusion: every name on these lists was put there by a foreign ministry. Where a state says no, it does not work.

In the conversation it quickly became concrete what “civil death” means in everyday life. The Swiss officer and author Jacques Baud, stuck in Brussels, may continue to publish and appear by video – he just may not take money for it, not a single euro in royalties. The journalist Hüseyin Doğru, not at all particularly pro-Russian, is completely isolated. And a Swiss-Cameroonian activist living in Africa lost, as soon as her name was on the list, her bank account, her credit card, even her access to Netflix and PayPal – because financial and platform service providers comply, or have to comply, with the sanctions. She could not even buy a domestic flight within Africa. This is how a globalised world carries every punishment into the farthest corner.

In the final chapter Hofbauer speaks of a selective martial law. Under martial law the state may seize property, requisition and billet people. Something similar applies to those sanctioned – only undeclared and tailored to individual persons. So are we at war? Hofbauer remains sober: “We are in the preparations.” He rejects as alarmist the talk of fascism that was hurled at him at a reading. What he observes is the movement towards an authoritarian state – a state that breaks its own basic laws, its own separation of powers.

Here his analysis met an observation that has long preoccupied us: the sanctions are a building block of propaganda – a defence against narratives considered dangerous. Hofbauer pins it down to energy prices. The prevailing reading blames the price rises on the Russian attack; in fact, by his calculation, prices rose as a result of the economic sanctions and the economic war unleashed by Europe and the USA. If this simple insight, which anyone can follow without a degree, were to prevail, politicians would come under pressure to justify themselves. And that brings us to the group that is at the heart of it all: the middle class. The academics, teachers, lawyers, journalists – those multipliers whose change of opinion at the Rotary Club or the tennis club becomes dangerous to the powerful. Dear viewers: if you are one of them, now you know: you are meant to be manipulated.

At the same time Hofbauer warned of a “double trap” between the nation state and the EU, in which democratic structures get caught and in which thousands of Brussels lobbyists find plenty of room. The 19th sanctions package is now in place; Hungary is blocking the 20th. Should the Union abolish the principle of unanimity, this corrective would also fall. It depends, he says, on elections – and on those countries that dig in their heels.

And the individual? In the end, the two speakers’ answer was strikingly hopeful and unspectacular. Do not fall into depression, do not be afraid, join together. Above all: read, and read together. Hofbauer recalls the reading circles, consumer and mutual-aid associations with which the workers’ movement of the 19th century grew big and strong. He recommends Fabian Scheidler’s “Friedenstüchtig” (“Fit for Peace”) as a counterpart to “war-readiness” and, half tongue-in-cheek, Heinrich Mann’s “Der Untertan” (“The Loyal Subject”) – that age-old book about how subjects are produced.

For the real preparation for war, we agreed, lies in isolation: in the vanished choral society, the dissolved village centre, in the atomisation that makes obedience easier. Protection, however, lies in community. “Singing and reading is always a good thing,” Hofbauer concluded. If only enough people understood this – perhaps five per cent would be enough – we would already have gained a great deal of room to manoeuvre.

 

See also NARRATIVE #02 with Dr. Hannes Hofbauer

Dr. Hannes HofbauerThis double mill that is being built up between the nation-state and the EU. Many democratic structures get caught in this double mill, and it offers a great deal of room for lobbying. So I can trace that quite well, since I've been making books for 30 years or more. For me, the bigger concern is the attention span of young people. That is, that people are no longer able to read longer texts. Interest in political topics has generally been rising again since Covid.

Robert CibisIt's about the civic middle. So, dear viewers, if you belong to it, you know you do. It's about you. That is the decisive vector that moves a society in one direction or another. And they have to be manipulated. My name is Robert Cibis. I'm very proud and honored to be sitting here with Dr. Hannes Hofbauer. Before we get down to business, I'd like to stress once more that all our content is on our website. www.oval.media. I don't know where you're watching this video right now. But please, please watch everything there. We are also present on other platforms. But that is somewhat less secure. Every now and then we get deleted or are not so easy to find. This website, at least until today, has always worked. Yes, and we have a very specific occasion. There is this new book that Hannes Hofbauer, as author and publisher, is making available to the world. And first I'd like to address the publisher role that Mr. Hofbauer has long used to give the world insights and convey analyses that it might not otherwise have had.

Download as PDF

Never miss a show

New films, shows and articles by email – free, unsubscribe anytime.

Title and name are optional.

Your comment