Prof. Dr. Fritz Vahrenholt | NARRATIVE #139 by Robert Cibis

Here is a version of about 30 minutes without restrictions – our OVALmedia subscribers can enjoy the full programme.

Werden Sie OVAL-Abo-Mitglied,

oder loggen Sie sich ein,

um dieses Video vollständig sehen zu können.

Audio onlyShort version · 26 min
Subscribers can listen to the full conversation (55:25). See OVAL subscriptionAlso as a podcast

Watch the full episode with OVAL Abo

Above you can watch a short version.

from €7 / month · cancel anytime · this and all other films, shows and articles

The Energy Deception

Robert Cibis learns from Prof. Dr. Fritz Vahrenholt why the narrative of the European “Green Deal” is a threat to Europe’s citizens. The scientist, wind power entrepreneur, former board member of energy companies and former environment senator of Hamburg has been working on energy supply in Germany for many decades. His bestseller “Die große Energiekrise … und wie wir sie bewältigen können”* (The Great Energy Crisis … and How We Can Overcome It) has not been mentioned in the legacy media, apart from the Bild newspaper. Is he putting his finger where it hurts? Why is it so bad to ask the simple and important questions about the security of energy supply?

*Also available in our bookshop (in German)!
Fritz Vahrenholt’s bestseller: “Die große Energiekrise … und wie wir sie bewältigen können.”



The Great Energy Crisis: A Compact Dialogue

Robert Cibis: Professor Vahrenholt, you are a chemist, a former environment senator and have held leading positions at RWE, Eon and Shell Germany. Your bestseller Die große Energiekrise sharply criticises current federal government policy. Although your expertise is undisputed, the book is hardly reviewed by the legacy media. How do you explain that?

Prof. Vahrenholt: The media increasingly see themselves as amplifiers of government policy and no longer as a critical authority. My book settles accounts with that and predicts that this course will fail and cost us prosperity.

Robert Cibis: In the book you point to several mistakes of the last ten years. The first big mistake was the nuclear phase-out in 2011, even though nuclear power is CO2-free and extremely cheap (about 2 cents per kilowatt hour). That was a purely emotional decision after Fukushima, and no country in the world has followed us.

Prof. Vahrenholt: Correct. We gave up 30% of our electricity supply and had to replace it with more expensive gas and coal. We should now at least develop new, inherently safe fourth-generation nuclear power plants.

Robert Cibis: A second dramatic mistake concerns industrial policy. Germany today has the highest electricity prices in the world (after Burkina Faso). Industry pays three to four times what is usual in the USA and China, which will inevitably cost jobs. In addition, our policy is counterproductive globally, because the relocation of efficient German production to China increases CO2 emissions worldwide.

Prof. Vahrenholt: On top of that comes the ideologically driven move away from the combustion engine and gas heating. The electric car is often more CO2-intensive than a diesel, because batteries are produced in China with a high input of coal. Symbolic politics creates fear in order to push through ideological goals.

Robert Cibis: You also address fracking gas. Germany bans the extraction of its own huge natural gas reserves (enough for 20–40 years), while we buy expensive imported fracking gas from the USA. You even reveal in the book that the anti-fracking campaigns in Germany were financially supported by the Russian president in order to secure sales of Russian gas.

Prof. Vahrenholt: Yes, this policy serves the interests of the USA, China and Russia, not those of Germany. Policy is determined by the primacy of ideology, not by economic reason or expertise.

Robert Cibis: What is your outlook? Will this policy come to an end?

Prof. Vahrenholt: If you pursue an ideology-oriented policy that ignores reality, it will fail. When citizens feel the scarcity and the unaffordable prices, the next federal election campaign will be an energy campaign. I hope people will then become more active and get involved politically to put Germany back on course.

Robert Cibis: Thank you very much for this illuminating conversation.

Robert CibisGood day, my name is Robert Cibis, and I warmly welcome you to a new episode of NARRATIVE. I am very proud and very honoured to be sitting here with Prof. Dr. Fritz Vahrenholt, an energy expert who can truly be called one. He knows energy supply issues from every perspective: from the academic one, he has published peer-reviewed papers, a whole series of them.

He was himself an entrepreneur, on the board of a wind power company with its own technology and its own patents, but at the same time also on the boards of RWE and Shell Germany, where he was likewise responsible for renewable energies. And of course environment senator in Hamburg, which many already know, and on top of that you are a trained chemist. That means this whole complex of energy supply in Germany and the world has obviously occupied you for decades. You are infinitely ahead of me and most viewers there, and that's why I am of course very keen to pepper you with questions. But I already have a bit of a reason now, because I have read this very exciting book; let me hold it up to the camera. It is, so to speak, the occasion for this conversation: "Die große Energiekrise" (The Great Energy Crisis), available in many places,

Download as PDF

Never miss a show

New films, shows and articles by email – free, unsubscribe anytime.

Title and name are optional.

Your comment