Carlos A. Gebauer | NARRATIVE #215 by Robert Cibis

Here is a version of about 30 minutes without restrictions – our OVALmedia subscribers can enjoy the full programme.

Audio onlyShort version · 30 min
Subscribers can listen to the full conversation (1:22:35). See OVAL subscriptionAlso as a podcast

Watch the full episode with OVAL Abo

Above you can watch a short version.

from €7 / month · cancel anytime · this and all other films, shows and articles

Liability for Power

Together with the lawyer, writer and philosopher Carlos A. Gebauer, Robert Cibis undertakes a dissection of modern state failure, an analysis of the global monetary system and a passionate plea for a new political ethic.

The anatomy of responsibility

“Responsibility” is a word politicians like to use, but Gebauer approaches the term not politically but from the philosophy of language. He breaks the German word “Verantwortung” down into its atoms: the prefix “ver-” often indicates that something disappears or changes place. At its core, responsibility is about “answering” – having to answer for oneself against an accusation or resistance.

Yet it is precisely this accountability that Gebauer sees as having been effectively abolished in current politics. While Robert Cibis remarks that responsibility in politics is often used only as a code for power and competence, Gebauer diagnoses a systematic “irresponsibility” in which political actors make decisions without having to bear the consequences.

The “plandemic” as a symptom of a sick financial system

A central and explosive point of the conversation is the question of why the globally synchronised measures crisis happened. Cibis and Gebauer discuss the thesis that the medical arguments often made no sense, but did make possible a political and economic restructuring of society.

Gebauer refers to the hypothesis of the philosopher Fabio Vighi: the world economy was not halted because of a virus, but to prevent the collapse of the global financial system. As early as 2019 a market collapse similar to 2008 was looming, but this time conventional means were no longer enough. The thesis: the real economy had to be put into an artificial coma (“throttled”) so that the freshly printed central bank money – the “fiat money” – stayed within the financial circuit and did not lead to hyperinflation in the real world.

Gebauer compares the financial system vividly to a drug addict: when the effect of the drug (cheap money) wears off, cold turkey looms. Instead of allowing this painful but healing withdrawal, the choice was made to give the addict ever higher doses in order to delay the collapse.

The silence of judges and doctors

Gebauer’s analysis from a lawyer’s perspective is particularly disturbing. He describes a historic failure of the judiciary: the courts failed to ask the decisive “question of fact”. Instead of taking evidence and examining facts independently, judges retreated to the position that authorities such as the RKI possessed infallible knowledge.

In this way, Gebauer says, the separation of powers was effectively undermined. When the judiciary no longer controls the executive but blindly trusts its authorities, the rule of law dies. He reports on judges who, out of sheer fear of taking responsibility for potential deaths, preferred to restrict fundamental rights rather than examine proportionality.

The medical profession does not escape unscathed either. Gebauer criticises that many doctors acted against their professional ethics by following instructions from non-doctors (politicians) instead of treating patients on their own responsibility. Following protocols replaced medical conscience – a phenomenon Cibis aptly describes as “soldierly”.

The way out: liability instead of moral appeals

But Gebauer and Cibis do not stop at this bleak assessment. How do we escape this “organised irresponsibility”? Gebauer’s proposed solution is as radical as it is compelling: liability.

He demands that politicians be personally liable for their decisions, much like the boards of public limited companies. Whoever negligently causes damage should answer for it with their private assets – for example up to the amount of one and a half years’ salary.

The logic behind this is compelling: liability law is quality management. As soon as a politician or adviser has to answer personally for wrong decisions, they will stop carrying out risky or ideological experiments on the population. The “mischief of the experts” who act in the background without risk would end immediately.

Gebauer also argues for a currency reform or the admission of parallel private currencies in order to escape the state monopoly on money and the inflationary policy that comes with it. Only through competition between currencies and real liability of decision-makers can freedom be regained.

Conclusion

This conversation is intellectual armour for the future. Anyone who wants to understand why institutions turn against citizens, why the monetary system determines our political actions and what a genuine democratic new beginning could look like cannot afford to miss this video.

You can find Carlos A. Gebauer’s website HERE

Robert CibisGood day, my name is Robert Cibis. I am very proud, very honoured to be sitting here with Carlos A. Gebauer. He is a publicist, a lawyer, also a lawyer for medical law, also known simply as an intellectual who talks about society and also about where it is not going or where it is going and where we perhaps should stop or look around. Before we get in medias res, I would like to point out that our programmes can all be seen on our website, www.oval.media. There are other platforms on which you may be watching this conversation right now, but we have found that nothing there lasts and we are often shadowbanned or deleted. And that includes everyone, also X, LinkedIn or Facebook. We have our own video server. We have really tried to be as independent as possible. If you have the choice,

please simply watch it on our website. We have both already spoken out on many topics independently of each other. We at OVALmedia are on the digital platforms precisely because, on the corona measures crisis, we spoke out at length. We made a great many programmes about it, documentaries and so on, and in doing so we found that it did not fit one hundred per cent with this free democratic basic order. It simply did not fit. Nor did it fit that a national government should bear any responsibility at all. Because we had the same absurd authoritarian measures in 196 countries, measures that made no medical sense at all, but politically of course led to a restructuring of society, a strengthening of the executive. And there you, as a lawyer, also stood up for, well, there is still the legal system, there are still structures that one ought to look at, and see what is actually right here, what is lawful and what would perhaps be ethically right, what would be morally right.

Download as PDF

Never miss a show

New films, shows and articles by email – free, unsubscribe anytime.

Title and name are optional.

Your comment