Billy Six | NARRATIVE #219 by Robert Cibis

Here is a version of about 35 minutes without restrictions – our OVALmedia subscribers can enjoy the full programme.

Audio onlyShort version · 34 min
Subscribers can listen to the full conversation (2:10:57). See OVAL subscriptionAlso as a podcast

Watch the full episode with OVAL Abo

Above you can watch a short version.

from €7 / month · cancel anytime · this and all other films, shows and articles

Suing the State

War reporter and political prisoner in Syria, Egypt and Venezuela: the case of Billy Six raises many questions… Filmmaker Robert Cibis has an in-depth conversation with the journalist Billy Six. Six, who as a reporter is often the only German at the world’s most dangerous hotspots, shares his wide-ranging experiences from global conflict zones, talks about his months-long imprisonment in a Venezuelan intelligence prison and reports on his historic legal victory against the German federal government. The interview unfolds a vivid panorama of the dangers of independent journalism and the failure of diplomatic institutions, and offers harsh criticism of the established media landscape.

Even at a young age, an insatiable curiosity drove Billy Six to the world’s trouble spots. Inspired by films such as “Wag the Dog”, which deal with the media staging of wars, he wanted to see the reality of geopolitical conflicts with his own eyes. This motivation took him hitchhiking from Berlin to South Africa and eventually, as a reporter, to the “Egyptian Spring”, the war in Libya and for weeks into the Syrian civil war. In Syria he travelled illegally, embedded himself with rebel groups and was even arrested by Assad’s army in open country. Six quickly realised there that the Western black-and-white picture of a spotless democracy movement against a dictatorship did not do justice to the highly complex, extremely brutal reality of a religious civil war.

His journalistic journey took a dramatic turn when he was refused entry to the USA in 2017 and, after being deported to Canada, spontaneously decided to fly to crisis-ridden Venezuela. There he benefited from the hyperinflationary currency crisis, which allowed him to stay in good hotels for a few dollars a night. He used this time to report intensively on the dilapidated Venezuelan oil industry, smuggling businesses and the violent opposition protests.

These investigations, however, proved his undoing. After a check at a remote discotheque, Six came to the attention of the authorities. A little later a special forces unit armed with machine guns stormed his hotel room and took him away. He was accused of espionage, of violating security zones – because he had photographed President Maduro with a zoom lens – and of rebellion. Six ended up in “El Helicoide” in the capital Caracas, a facility of the political intelligence service converted into a fortress, where the country’s most dangerous political prisoners were held.

While other imprisoned journalists from countries such as France or the USA were released within 48 hours thanks to massive diplomatic pressure from their governments, nothing happened in Billy Six’s case for months. According to Six, the German Foreign Office provided no effective help whatsoever and refrained from public protests or demands for his release. The authority’s supposed “lawyer referral” consisted merely of handing his parents a sheet of paper with twenty telephone numbers – completely useless for a prisoner without access to a telephone.

Rescue finally came from an entirely unexpected quarter. After being contacted by AfD politicians, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov intervened. Lavrov used a meeting in Vienna to press the Venezuelans through diplomatic channels for Six’s release, which Venezuela promptly granted. Particularly explosive: according to Six, the German federal government afterwards tried to sell the release as its own diplomatic success and even claimed to have no knowledge of Lavrov’s intervention, although there were official press releases about it from the Russian agency TASS.

After his return, Billy Six took the Foreign Office to court – for long stretches even without a lawyer. At the administrative court he initially failed because of a downright Kafkaesque reasoning: the judges ruled that he should not have sued now, but should have sued the Foreign Office while still in prison, from his Venezuelan cell.

The Federal Constitutional Court later demolished this ruling with a devastating justification. Germany’s highest court found in Six’s favour and stated that the previous ruling had flagrantly violated his fundamental right to be heard and to effective legal protection (Article 19). Of far greater weight, however, was the court’s factual finding: it was officially documented that the federal government had by no means publicly campaigned for his release or protested against his imprisonment. A minister had thus demonstrably lied to the Bundestag and the public about the supposed efforts, Six says. He concludes, disillusioned, that in Germany it evidently goes unpunished when members of the government lie to parliament to cover up political misconduct.

Besides his imprisonment, sharp criticism of reporting by the leading media is a central theme of the conversation. Cibis and Six describe the big publishing houses and public broadcasters as closely intertwined “system media” which – partly through covert research networks or state-favoured networks – support a uniform narrative. Cibis even draws historical parallels to the CIA’s “Operation Mockingbird”, through which American journalists were once steered by intelligence services, and warns that similar entanglements could be real today as well.

The Corona pandemic marked a turning point in Six’s life. In March 2020 he filmed empty corridors in Berlin’s Charité hospital, which stood in diametrical contrast to the media narrative of overcrowded hospitals. The video went viral within two to three hours and recorded 50,000 views before it was censored and rigorously deleted on YouTube. As a result, Six lost his job at the weekly newspaper “Junge Freiheit”, as even alternative editorial offices backed down under the pressure at the time.

Today Six looks to the future and is already planning new research trips, including to Russia and Brazil, where he has an invitation from former President Jair Bolsonaro.
In closing, Six and Cibis make an urgent appeal to the public not to let the events surrounding the Corona pandemic rest. The crisis, they say, revealed as if under a magnifying glass how government, leading media, science and corporations work together to exercise hybrid power. A complete reappraisal is a fundamental social duty; otherwise there is a danger that the “fear psychosis” that was created could be misused again in the future as a political lever to push through global agendas.

Hello, my name is Robert Cibis. Welcome to a new episode of NARRATIVE. Our episodes are always available in full on our website, www.oval.media. And I'm very proud and honored to be sitting here with Billy Six. He's a journalist who tackles the most mainstream topics there could possibly be. If something is hot and on the front page of the news every day, then chances are Billy Six has long since been there, on the ground. And the surprising thing is, he's often, let's say, usually the only one, or one of very few, at least from Germany, who are there and really look at what's happening. I suspect that a kind of adventurer gene plays a role there,

and maybe also some chronic curiosity. I think that might be something we have in common. And surely there's also a kind of need to draw attention to injustices and show people what's going wrong, in the hope that things will improve afterwards. Now, when you're at the hot spots, things actually happen that become hugely relevant, get instrumentalized by every side and get exploited. I'll just mention two things. He was the only journalist in Venezuela in recent years who really had to deal in depth with the regime, and was in the intelligence service prison. And then he was one of the few journalists who received no public attention in such a situation and actually got an incredible ruling from the Federal Constitutional

Never miss a show

New films, shows and articles by email – free, unsubscribe anytime.

Title and name are optional.

Your comment