Prof. Dr. Dr. David Berger | NARRATIVE #226 by Robert Cibis

Here is a version of about 30 minutes without restrictions – our OVALmedia subscribers can enjoy the full programme.

Audio onlyShort version · 33 min
Subscribers can listen to the full conversation (1:41:36). See OVAL subscriptionAlso as a podcast

Watch the full episode with OVAL Abo

Above you can watch a short version.

from €7 / month · cancel anytime · this and all other films, shows and articles

Cathocracy

In the “Narrative” series, Robert Cibis welcomes the publicist and theologian Prof. Dr. Dr. David Berger for a wide-ranging conversation that starts from a biography and leads from there to the fundamental questions of power, religion and the image of man. Berger, a professor at the Pontifical Academy of St. Thomas Aquinas from 2003 to 2010 and, by his own account, the youngest it ever had, worked through his years in the Vatican in the autobiographical book Der heilige Schein (“The Holy Pretence”). At the time he lived openly as a homosexual, but under cover within the Church: he passed off his long-term partner, he says, as a cousin, while higher-ranking clerics liked to introduce their partners as chauffeur or private secretary. The break came when Berger asked uncomfortable questions in connection with the Society of St. Pius X and the Holocaust denier Williamson, and was given to understand that his homosexuality was known and that loyalty and silence were therefore expected. Instead of letting himself be blackmailed, he went on the offensive, came out publicly and became a whistleblower.

From this experience Berger develops his central thesis, which still matters to him today: the apparent contradiction that the Catholic Church condemns homosexual men while to a large extent consisting of them is no contradiction at all once it is understood as an instrument of power. Practised homosexuality is regarded by the Church as a grave offence and makes those concerned open to blackmail; the most loyal priests were therefore often those with homosexual inclinations, and the density of such clerics increased with rank. The mechanism becomes truly diabolical where it is applied to sexual violence, to paedosexual offenders, and cover-up becomes a pledge of loyalty. Cibis responds with a deliberately provocative exaggeration: is the Church not, as a whole, a kind of “psyop” that replaced military rule with psychological operations, and an army and taxes with the tithe? Berger rejects the mixing of historical and present-day motives and pointedly defends the Church as a comparatively humane institution – measured against the French Revolution, the gulags and the concentration camps, he would always prefer a solemn High Mass with incense to a military parade in Moscow or Washington.

Much of the conversation is taken up by a historical narrative in which Berger interprets the conflict between secular and spiritual power – Augustine’s civitas terrena and civitas Dei – as the real engine of Western progress. This friction, he says, produced the first universities and, with the rediscovery of Aristotle by Albertus Magnus and Thomas Aquinas, made possible the emancipation of the secular sciences. In this reading Luther appears ambivalent: as the creator of a formative Bible translation, but at the same time as the “father of book burning” who, by breaking with Rome, delivered himself to the princes of the Empire, bloodily condemned the Peasants’ Revolt and fuelled the anti-Judaism of his time. Together, Cibis and Berger interpret the Reformation as a kind of “divide and rule” constellation in which the princes used Luther against the Catholic Habsburgs; Cibis draws the line to today’s geopolitics and the interest in setting Western Europe and Russia against each other.

From this past Berger derives his critique of the present: through the concordat, church tax and bishops’ salaries paid by the state, the German Church is closely tied to the state and is being domesticated – for example in railing against the AfD before elections. The Church only realises its true value as a “thorn in the flesh” of the powerful; its ultramontanism, its gaze across the Alps to Rome, guarantees a measure of freedom, unlike co-opted Protestantism.

From there the conversation turns to the Frankfurt School, which Berger describes as a turn from a metaphysical to a constructivist image of man. Using the example of Judith Butler and gender theory, he explains how sex supposedly only comes into being through the midwife’s performative speech act – for him an inversion that takes away from people what is given by nature and, in the guise of supposed freedom, subjects them to social constraints. Berger expressly stresses that discrimination against transsexual people is inhumane, that he himself has a transsexual friend and supports state assistance. His criticism is directed at the “trans hype”, self-declaration at the registry office and the early sexualisation of children, which he sees as a “war on truth” and as deliberate uprooting.

Cibis translates this into the image of a “technique of subjugation” and Stasi-style psychological subversion. In the same vein, both describe the Corona period as “diabolical”: pointless and harmful masks, traumatised young people, the vocabulary of “herd immunity” as dehumanisation, the ban on gatherings as an instrument of rule.

Sublimation becomes a connecting motif. With Freud, towards whom he is otherwise distant, Berger holds that power, religion and sexuality need to be “kept under a lid” so that civilisation does not break apart through excess. The office and its uniform domesticate the person – illustrated by the papal rite of the burning straw, which made the transience of worldly power visible. Sublimation also appears as the source of art, and suffering as something that gives meaning; this becomes vivid in the death of Berger’s grandmother, who died at the age of one hundred and one with the rosary in her hands, in what he describes as a moment of happiness. Against this he sets the transhumanist promise of a suffering-free, immortal human being, which he links to Harari, to Palantir and Thiel, and to the “Tower of Babel”: whoever tries to force heaven on earth creates hell, and a politics that no longer has to answer to anyone becomes irresponsible.

In response to Cibis’ persistent question about radical evil, Berger admits that years ago he would have dismissed Satanism as a conspiracy theory; an exorcism with Father Gabriele Amorth in Rome shook his prejudices, and he now considers the attraction of evil – half jokingly “especially strong in Berlin” – to be real. He interprets original sin as a habitus, translatable in secular terms, that is passed on. In closing, he contrasts Christianity with Islam, which he criticises as a religion of submission, presenting Christianity as a religion of grace and friendship with God that gives people back roots, identity and healing – the reason for the revival of faith he observes among young people. Cibis, a declared atheist and maker of documentaries about radical Christians, remains sceptical, but visibly wrestles with Harari’s concept of “shared fiction”, to which Berger opposes the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist. With Chesterton’s image of Catholics who dare the wildest games on an island because a protective wall prevents them from falling, a conversation ends that makes the art of limitation its common thread – along with Cibis’ observation that in uncertain times many people are once again longing for form, structure and something to hold on to.

David BergerThis trans hype just keeps going. It doesn't take the concerns of those people who are truly transsexual seriously at all. You explain that you just go to the registry office and say you're a woman. That naturally devalues things like a person's sexuality completely, just as sexuality is devalued by early sexualization. It's a very deliberate uprooting, and thus a weakening of the human being. And that's why the Corona period was such a diabolical and terrible time. But then stories kept surfacing where I said, yes, these conspiracy theories, the Pope with QAnon who drinks children's blood, there's a lot of nonsense there, where I said, from my experience in the Vatican, it's all nonsense, none of it works, these theories. But that radical evil exists,

that there is something like Satanism, is something I've increasingly had to learn over the past few years.

Download as PDF

Never miss a show

New films, shows and articles by email – free, unsubscribe anytime.

Title and name are optional.

Your comment