Peter Hahne | NARRATIVE #224 by Robert Cibis

Here is a version of about 30 minutes without restrictions – our OVALmedia subscribers can enjoy the full programme.

Audio onlyShort version · 22 min
Subscribers can listen to the full conversation (1:43:21). See OVAL subscriptionAlso as a podcast

Watch the full episode with OVAL Abo

Above you can watch a short version.

from €7 / month · cancel anytime · this and all other films, shows and articles

Germany’s Defect

In a pointed conversation with filmmaker Robert Cibis, former ZDF presenter, head of the Berlin studio and bestselling author Peter Hahne presents the central, highly critical theses of his book “Warum macht ihr uns kaputt?” (“Why Are You Destroying Us?”). In it, Hahne paints the disturbing picture of a nation whose substance, economy and infrastructure – symbolised by 58 crumbling bridges in the capital Berlin alone – are being systematically run into the ground by the current political leadership. For the commentator, this unprecedented decline is neither coincidence nor mere incompetence, but the result of an era of complete irresponsibility.

Whereas in earlier democratic phases politicians still showed decency and resigned after misconduct, today people who have incurred guilt are left in office or even promoted. Instead of serving the well-being of citizens, the political elite increasingly acts in an aloof parallel society which, together with the leading media, has moved miles away from the reality of people’s lives.

A central theme of the dialogue is the dramatic change in the media landscape, which Hahne, drawing on 52 years of experience as a journalist and presenter, sharply condemns. Where in the past the iron principle “facts, facts, facts” applied, so that citizens could form their own independent and mature opinions, today a governess-like journalism of attitude and mission prevails. Editorial teams and presenters now want to tell the audience what to think, confusing reporting with political education.

Robert Cibis adds to this observation by pointing out that since 2007 so-called “impact producing” has been taught quite openly at journalism schools and through EU funding programmes – the deliberate creation of political effect, which at its core is nothing other than propaganda. Hahne illustrates this creeping ideologisation with concrete examples, such as the graphic manipulation of election results on television, through which unpopular parties such as the AfD are deliberately made to look smaller and marginalised. The once strict separation and distance between press and politics, he says, no longer exists; we live in an elite tangle in which politicians and editors-in-chief are often very closely interwoven.

Both speakers identify the Corona measures crisis as the ultimate catalyst and eye-opener for this loss of democratic integrity. In their view, this “plandemic” showed in a frightening way how quickly fundamental rights could be suspended and critical experts – such as Professor Sucharit Bhakdi or Dr Wolfgang Wodarg – banished from public discourse and socially ostracised. Hahne describes the state’s conduct at the time as an attempt by politicians to test how far the people could be domesticated. Cibis and Hahne particularly sharply condemn the political hypocrisy surrounding the pandemic: while politicians enriched themselves with impunity through mask deals, the population was put under massive pressure.

Both point out that it had long been known that the vaccinations did not protect third parties from infection, and yet the narrative of the “pandemic of the unvaccinated” was relentlessly pushed in order to exclude the unvaccinated from society. Politicians such as Markus Söder or Federal President Frank-Walter Steinmeier, they say, prepared the ground during this period for a social division with a totalitarian feel, with words such as “parasites” or “rats”, in which the state operated primarily with fear, agitation and hatred.

In his analysis of Germany’s decline, Peter Hahne assigns a decisive role to former Chancellor Angela Merkel, whom he characterises on the one hand as a genius at power politics and on the other as completely unemotional and calculating. He accuses her of hollowing out the CDU’s substance and coldly eliminating rivals such as Helmut Kohl or Wolfgang Schäuble. To secure her power, he says, Merkel deliberately surrounded herself in the Chancellery with a circle of dependent and mediocre followers who could not hold a candle to her intellectually and were unconditionally loyal to her. Hahne regards the installation of Ursula von der Leyen as President of the EU Commission as her ultimate strategic move, through which Merkel’s influence lives on in Brussels to this day.

Hahne also draws explosive historical parallels with the GDR and points to Merkel’s family background through her father Horst Kasner, who, he says, operated in church structures infiltrated by the Stasi and the KGB. For Hahne and Cibis, the suspicion increasingly arises that it was not the Federal Republic that absorbed the GDR, but rather that the structures, networks and mentality of the GDR gradually took over the whole of reunified Germany – so that today Honecker is the one laughing last in history.

In this context the role of the churches is also sharply criticised. Hahne, who himself sat on the Council of the Protestant Church in Germany for years, accuses today’s church representatives of submitting completely and unconditionally to the spirit of the times and to government policy. Instead of offering theological and moral orientation, he says, the Western churches have been infiltrated by the radical left-wing ideas of the 1968 movement and today celebrate rainbow ideology and state doctrines. The churches went along with the Corona measures without criticism, thus repeating the fatal mistake of adapting to totalitarian systems that they had already made in the Nazi era.

Hahne regards the fact that politicians today are trying to intimidate uncomfortable critics with instruments such as the demand to abolish anonymity on the internet (a real-name requirement) as nothing more than a campaign of revenge by those in power against those who have brought uncomfortable truths to light in recent years.

Because of this assessment, which seems almost apocalyptic, the conversation culminates in a determined call for civil-society resistance. Hahne urgently warns the middle class against continuing to remain silent and passive. For the individual, this means standing up against ideological excesses in their immediate regional and local environment – whether with teachers, in day-care centres or at local political level. The growing return to homeland and identity, he says, is a loud cry for help from people against the destructive excesses of transnational forces. Robert Cibis, too, argues for a new form of self-determination, a kind of liberal community that cuts itself loose from overbearing, centralised power structures and is based on mutual help. In the end both agree: the key to real change lies in the fearless and visible commitment of each individual, in acting outside the control grid…

(HIER das vollständige Transkript, zum runterladen als PDF)

[/swpm_protected]

Germany’s Defect

In a pointed conversation with filmmaker Robert Cibis, former ZDF presenter, head of the Berlin studio and bestselling author Peter Hahne presents the central, highly critical theses of his book “Warum macht ihr uns kaputt?” (“Why Are You Destroying Us?”). In it, Hahne paints the disturbing picture of a nation whose substance, economy and infrastructure – symbolised by 58 crumbling bridges in the capital Berlin alone – are being systematically run into the ground by the current political leadership. For the commentator, this unprecedented decline is neither coincidence nor mere incompetence, but the result of an era of complete irresponsibility.

Whereas in earlier democratic phases politicians still showed decency and resigned after misconduct, today people who have incurred guilt are left in office or even promoted. Instead of serving the well-being of citizens, the political elite increasingly acts in an aloof parallel society which, together with the leading media, has moved miles away from the reality of people’s lives.

A central theme of the dialogue is the dramatic change in the media landscape, which Hahne, drawing on 52 years of experience as a journalist and presenter, sharply condemns. Where in the past the iron principle “facts, facts, facts” applied, so that citizens could form their own independent and mature opinions, today a governess-like journalism of attitude and mission prevails. Editorial teams and presenters now want to tell the audience what to think, confusing reporting with political education.

Robert Cibis adds to this observation by pointing out that since 2007 so-called “impact producing” has been taught quite openly at journalism schools and through EU funding programmes – the deliberate creation of political effect, which at its core is nothing other than propaganda. Hahne illustrates this creeping ideologisation with concrete examples, such as the graphic manipulation of election results on television, through which unpopular parties such as the AfD are deliberately made to look smaller and marginalised. The once strict separation and distance between press and politics, he says, no longer exists; we live in an elite tangle in which politicians and editors-in-chief are often very closely interwoven.

Both speakers identify the Corona measures crisis as the ultimate catalyst and eye-opener for this loss of democratic integrity. In their view, this “plandemic” showed in a frightening way how quickly fundamental rights could be suspended and critical experts – such as Professor Sucharit Bhakdi or Dr Wolfgang Wodarg – banished from public discourse and socially ostracised. Hahne describes the state’s conduct at the time as an attempt by politicians to test how far the people could be domesticated. Cibis and Hahne particularly sharply condemn the political hypocrisy surrounding the pandemic: while politicians enriched themselves with impunity through mask deals, the population was put under massive pressure.

Both point out that it had long been known that the vaccinations did not protect third parties from infection, and yet the narrative of the “pandemic of the unvaccinated” was relentlessly pushed in order to exclude the unvaccinated from society. Politicians such as Markus Söder or Federal President Frank-Walter Steinmeier, they say, prepared the ground during this period for a social division with a totalitarian feel, with words such as “parasites” or “rats”, in which the state operated primarily with fear, agitation and hatred.

In his analysis of Germany’s decline, Peter Hahne assigns a decisive role to former Chancellor Angela Merkel, whom he characterises on the one hand as a genius at power politics and on the other as completely unemotional and calculating. He accuses her of hollowing out the CDU’s substance and coldly eliminating rivals such as Helmut Kohl or Wolfgang Schäuble. To secure her power, he says, Merkel deliberately surrounded herself in the Chancellery with a circle of dependent and mediocre followers who could not hold a candle to her intellectually and were unconditionally loyal to her. Hahne regards the installation of Ursula von der Leyen as President of the EU Commission as her ultimate strategic move, through which Merkel’s influence lives on in Brussels to this day.

Hahne also draws explosive historical parallels with the GDR and points to Merkel’s family background through her father Horst Kasner, who, he says, operated in church structures infiltrated by the Stasi and the KGB. For Hahne and Cibis, the suspicion increasingly arises that it was not the Federal Republic that absorbed the GDR, but rather that the structures, networks and mentality of the GDR gradually took over the whole of reunified Germany – so that today Honecker is the one laughing last in history.

In this context the role of the churches is also sharply criticised. Hahne, who himself sat on the Council of the Protestant Church in Germany for years, accuses today’s church representatives of submitting completely and unconditionally to the spirit of the times and to government policy. Instead of offering theological and moral orientation, he says, the Western churches have been infiltrated by the radical left-wing ideas of the 1968 movement and today celebrate rainbow ideology and state doctrines. The churches went along with the Corona measures without criticism, thus repeating the fatal mistake of adapting to totalitarian systems that they had already made in the Nazi era.

Hahne regards the fact that politicians today are trying to intimidate uncomfortable critics with instruments such as the demand to abolish anonymity on the internet (a real-name requirement) as nothing more than a campaign of revenge by those in power against those who have brought uncomfortable truths to light in recent years.

Because of this assessment, which seems almost apocalyptic, the conversation culminates in a determined call for civil-society resistance. Hahne urgently warns the middle class against continuing to remain silent and passive. For the individual, this means standing up against ideological excesses in their immediate regional and local environment – whether with teachers, in day-care centres or at local political level. The growing return to homeland and identity, he says, is a loud cry for help from people against the destructive excesses of transnational forces. Robert Cibis, too, argues for a new form of self-determination, a kind of liberal community that cuts itself loose from overbearing, centralised power structures and is based on mutual help. In the end both agree: the key to real change lies in the fearless and visible commitment of each individual, in acting outside the control grid…

Peter HahneThey are destroying the economy, they are destroying the infrastructure. In Berlin, 58 bridges are broken. Where are Putin's tanks supposed to roll then? This is all madness. We have a completely broken country. You just said you are breaking everything. Do you think this person is aware that you

Robert Cibisare doing that? Hello, and welcome to a new episode of NARRATIVE. My name is Robert Cibis. Our episodes are always available in full on our website, www.oval.media. And I am very proud and honored to be sitting here today with Peter Hahne. A face everyone knows, and a voice that probably everyone knows as well. And the occasion for our conversation is a new book. This one here: "Why Are You Destroying Us?" The title is of course telling, because we keep hearing this voice saying Germany must not become too strong. Germany must not be too big. Don't get ahead of yourselves. There is a kind of psycho-narrative that has burdened me and people of my generation the whole time. And then I came to England or France and always heard how proud they were of their flag and their country. And I always found that a bit ridiculous. I thought, what is all this nonsense? A country is just an illusion, after all. In the end, we are all human beings. And perhaps one is more of a European than

Download as PDF

Never miss a show

New films, shows and articles by email – free, unsubscribe anytime.

Title and name are optional.

Your comment