Prof. Dr. Gertrud Höhler | NARRATIVE #203 by Robert Cibis

Here is a version of about 25 minutes without restrictions – our OVALmedia subscribers can enjoy the full programme.

Audio onlyShort version · 22 min
Subscribers can listen to the full conversation (1:15:07). See OVAL subscriptionAlso as a podcast



Watch the full episode with OVAL Abo

Above you can watch a short version.

from €7 / month · cancel anytime · this and all other films, shows and articles

Homo Creator

Prof. Dr. Gertrud Höhler is a critical intellectual who became a systemic dissident with her Merkel trilogy (“Die Patin”, “Demokratie im Sinkflug” and “Angela Merkel – Das Requiem”). Most recently, with “Die Corona-Bilanz. Die Würde des Menschen ist unantastbar” (“The Corona Balance Sheet: Human Dignity Is Inviolable”), she showed the continuity of the dismantling of democracy after Merkel. Since the 1960s the literary scholar has written many bestsellers and advised the powerful of the Federal Republic. That is why, like hardly anyone else, she can help us “zoom back” and recognise the great “world fire”.

Prof. Höhler laments a transformation of the human being into a human machine. Together with filmmaker Robert Cibis she discusses the attacks on citizens, which seem so fundamental that one can speak of an assault on humanity. The levers are ideology and the collectivism associated with it. The extreme, she says, can be found in the contradictory understanding of children’s education: children grow up more isolated than before, are increasingly drilled to obey, and so live ever more alike and joylessly.

But only in diversity does freedom flourish, and only with the feeling of being able to have influence can life be fulfilled. The loss of basic trust, she says, is a decisive step towards an authoritarian society.

Summary of the conversation: the ideology of decline

Robert Cibis: Professor Höhler, you are known as a critical intellectual, literary scholar and writer who has dealt intensively with processes of cultural change. You argue that cultural history is also the history of religion and above all the history of ideology. From this perspective, how do you assess global developments?

Prof. Höhler: What is happening worldwide is far removed from the “cosy-sounding” Zeitenwende (turning point). I see the West grappling with the unknown, and an uncertainty about how much longer we will hold our top position in the world.

Robert Cibis: You see big changes in the way children are treated, which you describe as a worldwide collective determination. Instead of the protective family home, infants under twelve months are placed in collective care early on. What is the consequence?

Prof. Höhler: We organise children like little soldiers. Early childhood collectivisation leads to a cooling of the child’s basic expectations. The child’s basic trust in adults and the formation of archaic bonds are undermined.

Robert Cibis: I saw this collective oppression particularly during the Corona crisis, for example with FFP2 masks for children. You see in it a danger to society as a whole and speak of the “suicide of cultures”.

Prof. Höhler: That’s right. It is no longer about achievement, but about an attitude that moves away from economic and intellectual effort. Homo sapiens is by nature a runner and loves competition. If he is not allowed to compete, he loses his joy in life. We are on a “losers’ road”.

Robert Cibis: You stress that diversity is the core of freedom. How do the new technologies threaten us?

Prof. Höhler: Autocratic concepts from Asian countries are admired here, because people believe one must likewise treat people ruthlessly. The new technology is decreed as a fateful development. Artificial intelligence (AI) is the guarantee of mediocrity, since it is based only on existing material and invents no creativity.

Robert Cibis: Do you see the collection and storage of digital health data and the growing authority of the state as a training programme to make citizens compliant?

Prof. Höhler: Yes. It is an interest in power. The aim is to train people “so that they don’t get in the way”. Whoever is no longer allowed to be different has lost their freedom. This authoritarian behaviour also resonates with young people who long for “decisive commands” and strong leaders.

Robert Cibis: Many of your analyses are fundamental. What is the deeper cause of this German tendency towards the losers’ position and the readiness for suicide?

Prof. Höhler: In Germany, the trauma of insufficiently processed history as the perpetrator of violence in the world war plays a role. Germans experience it as a relief to be on the losers’ road, so as not to be attacked. We have a collective listlessness about standing up for high values.

Robert Cibis: What is the solution when politics itself seems corrupted and leaders are chosen not for brilliance but for belonging?

Prof. Höhler: We are witnessing the dismantling of all the values that are vital for democracy. The only power that counts is respect for the human being and for his basic need for drive and achievement. If we continue to disregard this attentiveness and children’s ability to play and understand, we should not be surprised at our failure.

Read also:

Freud’s Psychoanalysis: The Great Forgery

Books by Prof. Dr. Gertrud Höhler (in German)

  • Die Patin. Wie Angela Merkel Deutschland umbaut. Orell Füssli, Zurich 2012
  • Demokratie im Sinkflug: Wie sich Angela Merkel und EU-Politiker über geltendes Recht stellen. FinanzBuch, Munich 2017
  • Angela Merkel – Das Requiem, Ullstein, Berlin 2020
  • Die Corona-Bilanz. Die Würde des Menschen ist unantastbar, Heyne, Munich 2020

Robert CibisHello, my name is Robert Cibis. Welcome to a new episode of Narrative. I'm very proud and very honoured to be sitting here with Prof. Dr. Höhler. I'd like to point out straight away that our programmes can always be seen in full on our website www.oval.media. Ms Höhler is known as a writer and commentator, known also for having been very present in the German media for a long time and for having written many bestsellers, but she is also a management consultant, a literary scholar, simply an intellectual who has always had a critical mind. I'd just like to cite two books that are lying here right now. Die Würde des Menschen ist unantastbar, a book on the Corona crisis, and of course the very famous book Die Patin about Angela Merkel.

Prof. Dr. Gertrud HoehlerYes, of course, through my training, which I had chosen myself, that is literary studies, medieval and modern, and art history: by choosing these subjects I had already found an interest in the behaviour of people under various cultural processes of change particularly interesting. And then it's the case that you come into contact with young people. At least at the beginning of my university career in the 1960s it was the case that young people sat there who also wanted to understand history through the history of literature. And I know that we all had a common teacher, who always said: don't forget, cultural history is also religious history. And today we could add, the two of us, we could above all say, it is also the history of ideology, the history of ideas, of what suddenly seizes whole peoples, floods whole continents. That which people today then try to define away from the human being with terms like Zeitenwende, a turning point in history, whereby Zeitenwende sounds very cosy compared with what is actually going on

Download as PDF

Never miss a show

New films, shows and articles by email – free, unsubscribe anytime.

Title and name are optional.

Your comment