Prof. Dr. Christoph Lütge | NARRATIVE #211 by Robert Cibis

Here is a version of about 30 minutes without restrictions – our OVALmedia subscribers can enjoy the full programme.

Audio onlyShort version · 30 min
Subscribers can listen to the full conversation (1:34:11). See OVAL subscriptionAlso as a podcast

Watch the full episode with OVAL Abo

Above you can watch a short version.

from €7 / month · cancel anytime · this and all other films, shows and articles



Ethics Knocked Out?

Robert Cibis meets Professor Dr. Christoph Lütge, professor of business ethics and director of the Institute for Ethics in Artificial Intelligence. Where do the economy and society stand since the measures crisis of 2020–22, and also in view of the disruptive role of artificial intelligence (AI)? Cibis stresses that recent events have caused massive cognitive dissonance, which makes it necessary to ask fundamental questions, especially in view of widespread dysfunction in German society.

AI regulation as a weapon

Prof. Lütge sees clear evidence that lobbying was carried out in Europe by actors from the USA to push AI regulation forward. As the “best example” he names Sam Altman of OpenAI, who gave talks in which he basically called for regulation, although he knew that this would not happen in the same way in the USA. Cibis asks whether this is a subversive attack on European competitiveness, which Prof. Lütge confirms and calls “impossible to deny”.

Europe, he says, lags massively behind in AI: only 5% of AI computing power is generated in Europe, while 85% takes place in the USA. The European tendency towards an “orgy of regulation” (such as the AI Act, the Digital Markets Act and the Digital Services Act) harms European companies, especially small and medium-sized businesses and start-ups, as they cannot afford their own compliance departments, which are a matter of course for large platforms. This over-regulation is counterproductive, he says, since hardly anyone in the world apart from Europe supports such tough regulation. Last year the Draghi report on Europe’s competitiveness acknowledged this problem, saying in effect: “We are killing our own companies”.

Ethics in AI

Instead of rigid regulation, Prof. Lütge favours so-called soft governance – guidelines and principles that offer orientation but do not have to be laid down in every last detail. The best-case scenario, he says, is to have functioning ethical principles that are also in the interest of companies and organisations, since users only use systems if they trust them. Trust is crucial, for example in autonomous vehicles or in healthcare, where AI can save lives. Trust-building measures could include quality seals or external services to monitor data use.
The discussion also touches on the use of data: Lütge sees hurdles in Germany that are too high for using patient data to train AI models. Those who do not do this, he says, get the data from abroad (China, the USA). He stresses that attention must be paid to the possible emergence of surveillance scenarios. Asked about the concern whether AI itself led to insidious concentrations of power (as during the measures crisis of 2020–22), Lütge says no, since generative AI (GenAI) only really took off at the end of 2022. He distinguishes GenAI (e.g. ChatGPT, which generates texts, images and films) from artificial general intelligence (AGI), which could replicate human abilities in all essential respects. He expresses doubt whether current progress already represents a fundamental step towards AGI, i.e. the singularity, or even towards systems with consciousness.

The Bavarian Ethics Council and a “witch hunt”

Robert Cibis pays tribute to Lütge for his steadfastness, since he holds critical positions despite the disadvantages. Prof. Lütge reports on his experiences, particularly in connection with his removal from the Bavarian Ethics Council. He had spoken out controversially there about the lockdowns and other measures. This led to a “veritable media witch hunt” in the Süddeutsche Zeitung, in which he was accused of wanting old people to die, although he had merely pointed out that the average age of “Corona deaths” was above the normal average age at death. Shortly afterwards he was removed from the body without any reason being given. He suspects political interests in the background that would not tolerate critical voices, especially as this happened at a time when candidacies for chancellor were also at stake. This critical stance led to disadvantages, including the loss of research funding and the breakdown of professional relationships.

Coming to terms with it as a society

Lütge stresses that he considers a social reappraisal of the measures crisis a priority in order to bridge the divides in society. He criticises that hardly anything has happened in Germany in this respect, while in other countries (e.g. the USA) political events or elections have already forced more of a reappraisal.

Lütge and Cibis criticise the way the measures were implemented politically and sold by the media. Lütge points out that politicians liked to rely on “the science”, which seemed to tell them something unambiguous, but which “had, so to speak, been ordered” (e.g. statements by the Leopoldina). The length of time the measures lasted was disproportionate, he says, especially the second lockdown from November 2020, whose coordination must also be investigated. Unlike Germany, where the debates hardly took place in parliament, Lütge sees a sharper parliamentary debate in other countries (such as England). During this time, he says, the ethics councils often served to justify ethically, after the fact, measures that had already been decided politically.
As a strong argument that the measures were excessive, Lütge cites the absence of influenza during the crisis, which was also observed in Sweden – a country without lockdowns, 3G or 2G rules. He criticises politicians’ growing “mania for control” and the far-reaching powers of the EU institutions, which lack critical checks. As an alarming example he names the EU-wide obligation to install control systems in new cars that warn against speeding and even intervene in the steering.

Recommendation

Prof. Lütge advises viewers to inform themselves impartially and independently, to maintain a healthy mistrust, but not to be fundamentally negative about innovation. He stresses that digitalisation is a tool that offers opportunities and can have an emancipatory effect. The decisive thing is to keep the debates going and to raise one’s voice in order to strengthen a democratic and open society. He is optimistic that plurality among AI providers will continue to develop despite concentration.

See also:

AI – No Salvation – NARRATIVE #155 with Dr. Martin Braake

Elon Musk’s Wrong Turn – NARRATIVE #132 with Dr. Jobst Landgrebe

Prof. Dr. Christoph LütgeThere's clear evidence for it. Lobbying was carried out here in Europe by people from the USA. The best example I experienced myself: Sam Altman of OpenAI. He came here, to my university too, by the way, and gave talks in which he basically called for regulation of AI. But of course he knows that won't happen like that in the USA. Even before Trump. Both governments basically only had a slightly graded, somewhat stricter attitude to AI, but not really.

Robert CibisWas that a subversive attack on European competitiveness? You have to put it that way.

Never miss a show

New films, shows and articles by email – free, unsubscribe anytime.

Title and name are optional.

Your comment